CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY idx_order_created ON "order"(created_at) DROP INDEX IF EXISTS idx_order_created Setting runInTransaction="false" means that if the changeSet fails mid-execution, the already-executed statements within it are not automatically rolled back — you may be left with a partially applied changeSet. This is an acceptable trade-off for operations that genuinely cannot run in a transaction (like concurrent index creation, which cannot hold a table lock for the duration of a transaction in PostgreSQL). A changeSet with runInTransaction="false" should contain the minimum number of operations necessary, and the rollback block becomes critical since Liquibase will not automatically undo partial work if the changeSet fails."> CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY idx_order_created ON "order"(created_at) DROP INDEX IF EXISTS idx_order_created Setting runInTransaction="false" means that if the changeSet fails mid-execution, the already-executed statements within it are not automatically rolled back — you may be left with a partially applied changeSet. This is an acceptable trade-off for operations that genuinely cannot run in a transaction (like concurrent index creation, which cannot hold a table lock for the duration of a transaction in PostgreSQL). A changeSet with runInTransaction="false" should contain the minimum number of operations necessary, and the rollback block becomes critical since Liquibase will not automatically undo partial work if the changeSet fails." />

Prev Next

Database / Liquibase interview questions

How does Liquibase handle transactions during migration?

By default, Liquibase wraps each changeSet in a database transaction. If any change within a changeSet fails, the entire changeSet is rolled back and Liquibase stops. This transactional wrapper ensures that a changeSet either succeeds completely or leaves the database unchanged — partial application of a changeSet is prevented.

However, not all SQL statements can run inside a transaction in all databases. For example, CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY in PostgreSQL, DDL statements in Oracle (which auto-commit), and some MySQL table operations are not transactional. For these cases, Liquibase provides the runInTransaction attribute on a changeSet:

<changeSet id="create-index-concurrently" author="henry" runInTransaction="false">
    <sql>CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY idx_order_created ON "order"(created_at)</sql>
    <rollback>
        <sql>DROP INDEX IF EXISTS idx_order_created</sql>
    </rollback>
</changeSet>

Setting runInTransaction="false" means that if the changeSet fails mid-execution, the already-executed statements within it are not automatically rolled back — you may be left with a partially applied changeSet. This is an acceptable trade-off for operations that genuinely cannot run in a transaction (like concurrent index creation, which cannot hold a table lock for the duration of a transaction in PostgreSQL).

A changeSet with runInTransaction="false" should contain the minimum number of operations necessary, and the rollback block becomes critical since Liquibase will not automatically undo partial work if the changeSet fails.

What does Liquibase do by default when a changeSet fails mid-execution?
In which scenario is runInTransaction="false" necessary on a PostgreSQL database?

Invest now in Acorns!!! 🚀 Join Acorns and get your $5 bonus!

Invest now in Acorns!!! 🚀
Join Acorns and get your $5 bonus!

Earn passively and while sleeping

Acorns is a micro-investing app that automatically invests your "spare change" from daily purchases into diversified, expert-built portfolios of ETFs. It is designed for beginners, allowing you to start investing with as little as $5. The service automates saving and investing. Disclosure: I may receive a referral bonus.

Invest now!!! Get Free equity stock (US, UK only)!

Use Robinhood app to invest in stocks. It is safe and secure. Use the Referral link to claim your free stock when you sign up!.

The Robinhood app makes it easy to trade stocks, crypto and more.


Webull! Receive free stock by signing up using the link: Webull signup.

More Related questions...

What is Liquibase and what problem does it solve? What is a changeLog in Liquibase? What is a changeSet in Liquibase and how is it identified? What are the DATABASECHANGELOG and DATABASECHANGELOGLOCK tables? What is the difference between Liquibase and Flyway? What are contexts in Liquibase and how do you use them? What are labels in Liquibase and how do they differ from contexts? How does rollback work in Liquibase? What is a Liquibase precondition and why would you use one? How do you integrate Liquibase with Spring Boot? What are Liquibase change types and can you name common ones? What is the Liquibase diff command and when is it useful? What are Liquibase tags and how do you use rollback to a tag? What is runOnChange and runAlways in a Liquibase changeSet? What is the markNextChangeSetRan and markNextChangeSetRanSQL command used for? How do you manage Liquibase changeLog files in a multi-module Maven project? What is the Liquibase updateSQL command and when is it used? What is a Liquibase snapshot and what commands use it? What is the failOnError attribute in a changeSet and when should you set it to false? How does Liquibase handle transactions during migration? What is the Liquibase Hub and what does it provide? How do you use Liquibase with multiple databases or schemas in a single application? What is the Liquibase Pro checksum validity and how do clearCheckSums and validChecksums work? What are Liquibase custom change types and how do you create one? How do you handle large table migrations in Liquibase without causing downtime? What is the Liquibase Maven plugin and how do you run migrations with it? What is the Liquibase status command and how does it differ from validate? What are Liquibase property substitution and how does it work? How do you write Liquibase changeLogs in YAML format? What is the Liquibase formatted SQL changeLog format? What is the Liquibase updateTestingRollback command? How do you use Liquibase with Docker and Testcontainers in integration tests? What is the difference between addColumn with a default value and a nullable column in Liquibase for large tables? What is liquibase.properties and what configuration belongs in it?
Show more question and Answers...

MuleESB

Comments & Discussions